Derby's busy roads have sparked a heated debate, with a 'conspiracy' claim being refuted by the city's transport leader. The controversy revolves around a camera at a busy junction, which has fined hundreds of drivers, sparking concerns about fairness and road signage.
The ANPR camera, located at the junction of Cathedral Road and St Alkmund's Way/Ford Street, has raised eyebrows among some residents. Critics argue that it may be unfairly targeting drivers, while others defend its purpose in addressing illegal parking and its impact on emergency services.
The council claims the camera is essential for penalizing drivers who stop in marked areas, citing evidence of ambulance delays caused by blocked junctions. However, the city's Conservative deputy leader has questioned the camera's fairness, suggesting it catches both honest mistakes and reckless driving.
A Freedom of Information request revealed the council generated nearly £55,000 in 2025 from the camera, with 1,938 drivers fined between January and December. Fines are up to £70, but drivers can reduce them to £35 if paid within 14 days.
Councillor Carmel Swan, the cabinet member for transport, faced scrutiny at a meeting. Conservative councillor Matthew Holmes inquired about pre-enforcement assessments and concerns of unintended driver penalties. He highlighted public perception of the camera as a 'cash cow.'
Cllr Swan strongly denied any conspiracy to trap unsuspecting drivers, emphasizing her inability to address individual cases or take responsibility for those who ignore road signs. She cited signage assessments as a regulated process.
Councillor Jonathan Smale shared similar concerns, citing the camera's location near a hill and its potential to catch drivers off guard. A council spokesperson defended the camera, emphasizing the impact of illegal parking on emergency services and the need to address significant delays.
